|
Below, you'll find extensive information
on leading intellectual property attorneys articles and products to help you on your
way to success.
Intellectual Property: Patents - Drafting with Reasonable Care and Skill
By Dr R Cooper
In the case of Unilin Beheer BV v Berry Floor NV & Ors, Information Management Consultancy Ltd, B&Q plc (2005), the courts ruled that the faulty drafting of a patent application did not amount to lack of reasonable care and skill.
Unilin, the claimant, applied for a patent for a floor covering and the application succeeded. Unilin then became aware of prior art which made it necessary for it to amend the patent application by reducing the scope of the main claim. Unilin also amended the body of the specification so that the text and drawings conformed to the main claim.
After grant of the patent, Unilin sued three defendants for patent infringement. The defendants counterclaimed, arguing that a
All Headline News - Breaking News
The latest top breaking news, U.S., world, business, politics, entertainment, celebrities, sports, technology, and more.
(AHN) Two Infants Die In Arizona Car Crash
A case of rubber-necking turned deadly for two young children in Arizona over the weekend. - (AHN)
(AHN) Las Vegas Casino Evacuated After Bomb Scare
A man walked into a Las Vegas casino wearing what looked like an explosives belt Saturday morning, prompting security to evacuate the building and a nearby RV park. - (AHN)
(AHN) Ohio Man Indicted For Locking Up, Abusing Family For 15 Years
Out on a $250,000 bail bond, an Ohio man has pleaded "not guilty" to charges including rape, gross sexual imposition, domestic violence and child endangerment, allegedly committed against his wife and seven children over the course of 15 years. - (AHN)
(AHN) Earl Fizzles, Gaston To Form
Federal weather forecasters say the storm system called Gaston has a high chance of reforming into a tropical cyclone over the next two days. - (AHN)
(AHN) New Farmlands Driving Out Forests Causes Climate Change Study Says
More than 80 percent of new farmlands in tropical countries have come from the felling of trees, increasing the release into the atmosphere of carbon that causes global warming, a study has found. The expansion of farmlands is expected to increase due to growing global demand for agricultural products. - (AHN)
(AHN) Craiglist Blocks U.S. Access To Controversial Adult Ads
Online classified ad site Craigslist blocked access to its controversial adult services section Saturday morning. - (AHN)
piece of prior art (Yoichi) had not been cited against the patent.
On 26 September 2003, the court held that Claims 1-19 of the patent were invalid in respect of the prior art Yoichi but Claims 20 and 21 were valid and infringed by the defendant. Unilin claimed damages for past infringements and costs.
The defendants contended that Unilin could not claim damages by way of s.63 (2) of the Patents Act 1977 whereby a court cannot grant any relief if a patent is only partially valid unless it is proven that the patent was framed in good faith and with reasonable care and skill. The defendants argued that Unilin did not frame the patent with reasonable care and skill.
Unilin's patent contained a limitation that the floor covering panels substantially consist of HDF or MDF board and that there should be a snap together connection. These limitations were not essential when the patent was first applied for, so the amendments that Unilin made were to make MDF/HDF and snap-fit essential. Unilin also amended the description so it conformed to the amended claim. The defendants said that Unilin failed to exercise reasonable care and skill in amending the description.
The Court of Appeal held that:
? the specification as a whole was drafted with reasonable care and skill;
? if there was some irrelevant but harmless information in the specification this did not mean it was not drafted without reasonable care and skill; and
? the specifications were not misleading.
The appeal was therefore dismissed and Unilin and it was ruled that would be paid damages and costs.
Comment: Please contact us for more information on applying for a patent.
Email: enquiries@rtcoopers.com
Visit http://www.rtcoopersiplaw.com or http://www.rtcoopers.com/practice_intellectualproperty.php
© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.
Dr Coopers is an IP expert
|
|
We strive to provide only quality articles, so if there is
a specific topic related to intellectual property attorneys that you would like us
to cover, please contact us at any time.
And again, thank you to those contributing daily to our intellectual property attorneys
website.
|
